The death of a pope; convoking of a conclave! Heady, exciting times for us serious Catholics!
With many others, I breathe a sigh of relief that the Francis era is past. But I am not building up my hopes for the conclave and new pope. I am quietly, serenely detaching from the Vatican, in order to love the Church more passionately, soberly, purely.
We make too much of the papacy. It is overrated. He is our Supreme Pontiff, our dear vicar of Christ on earth, worthy (whatever his personal flaws) of our affection, reverence, loyalty and obedience. He is a significant, but small part of the magnificent edifice that is the Roman Catholic Church. There is so much more besides the papacy. The Holy Spirit is working in millions of ways, whatever the bishop of Rome is doing.
Widely, we have developed a co-dependency upon the papacy. A spiritual regression. A lack of wholesome subsidiary. An diminishment of the local-concrete-specific and an exaggeration of the upper tier, the distant, the top of the hierarchy. This is analogous to our American politics: we see in recent months widespread derangement symptoms on the left because Trump won the election. And so within the Church, we do well to "get our own lives" as we draw closer together in worship, attention to the Word, service, mutual charity and delight.
Global media is part of the problem. Any ill-considered, throw-away comment by a fatigued, elderly pope returning on a jet from an exhausting trip becomes major news around the globe.
Celebrity culture is a problem. The hero of my youth was John F. Kennedy; the hero of my adulthood John Paul II. Can you think of anyone, in our lifetime or even the history of mankind, in their league with regard to super-intelligence, charisma, charm, vigor, moral vision, raw masculine appeal, and a mysterious radiance of leadership? Both also had a deep seated humility. But they left a cultural legacy of celebrityhood in regard to leadership. Donald Trump is fundamentally a celebrity. Pope Francis was a celebrity. There is something to be said for the boring, industrious, modest fidelity to the institution of a Pius XII, Paul VI, Benedict or even the two Bushes.
By a spiritual subsidiarity we do well to recognize the workings of the Holy Spirit at every level of the Church, but primarily at the concrete, specific, local...the parish, the local priest, the prayer group, friendship circle or family. The decisions and words of the pope do matter; but not as much as family prayer; or forgiveness; or concrete acts of charity. We overrate the papacy.
Progressives widely anticipated the "Francis Effect" which would bring a breeze of liberation in the Church including increased mass attendance, conversions and an open, welcome atmosphere. After 12 years, we have decreased attendance; large numbers leaving the Church; a polarized, hostile divide; and disappointment among both progressives and conservatives. More surprising: priestly vocations are level or slightly down but there are virtually NO seminarians and young priests in the mode of Francis. We have almost two generations of "John Paul and Benedict" priests and seminarians ever more traditional. There are "Francis cardinals and bishops" but no "Francis Priests."
This is surely the nightmare of our recently deceased pontiff and his generation: more "rigidity, regression, clericalism, dogmatism, legalism!" His first exercise in purgatory will surely be a clear-eyed vision of the effects on the Church of his leadership. His second purgative exercise may well be an unending synodal session in which he listens to, reverently embraces and seeks pardon from all those cassock-wearing, Latin-praying, canon-law-abiding, novena-counting, dogma-loving, tradition-conserving clerics...past, present, and future... he has so long disparaged. (Can you, dear reader, please obtain a plenary indulgence for him? I have a previous list I am working on and will not get to him before the end of the Jubilee Year!)
Christ is the head of the Church; he is the Bridegroom; he is our captain. The pope is a vicar. Often flawed and defective. But he is still our father. As we pray for the repose of Francis and anointing of the Holy Spirit on the conclave of cardinals, we mostly open our hearts to the workings of our Lord in our own concrete, small, specific locations.
Come Holy Spirit!