Friday, May 16, 2025

Most Influential American Catholic Theologians of the Last 80 Years

The critique (on today's First Thing's website) of recently deceased Fr. David Tracey by Monsignor Tom Guarino...respectful, insightful, lucid and (miraculously) metaphysically user-friendly...provoked a question: Who are the most influential Catholic American theologians (for better or for worse) since WWII? 

(You are well aware, kind reader, of how Fleckinstein loves top-ten-type lists!)

Regarding professional theologians and influence on the guild and thereby on the Church and society, I go with a first team of:

-Courtney Murray.

-Oestrreicher.

-Dulles.

-Tracey.

-D.L. Schindler.

-R. Brown.

-Hahn.

Expanding "American" to include those north and south of USA we need to include:

-Lonergan (Canadian).

-Gutierrez (Peruvian).

-Boff (Brazilian).

The best theological minds of our hierarchy would be:

-George.

-Chaput.

-Sheen.

-Barron.

Since philosophy is so close to theology we might also include: 

-McLuhan (Canadian).

-MacIntyre.

-Kreeft.

-Grant (Canadian). 

More popular, less academic but widely influential theologians:

-Merton.

-Nouwen.

-Rohr.

-Novak.

-Neuhaus.

-Weigel.

-Groeschel.

-Von Kam.

Important women theologians (Disclaimer: Fleckinstein is not a student of feminist theology.)

-J. Smith.

-M. Healy

-E. Johnson.

-R. Reuther.

Who, dear Reader, would you add? Delete? Do not be shy to "comment."


No comments: