Today, I privately, quietly celebrate 80 years of existence. Born 8/20/1947, my conception calculates roughly to Nov. 20, 1946, 80 years ago today. A good time to look back, reflect, give thanks.
Exulting in a Holy Memory
My first, prime blessing: the love between our mother and father. Modest, discrete, and chaste in classic Catholic form, they were in love...tenderly, reverently, passionately...for over 50 years. They exemplified the wisdom: "The best thing a man can do for his children is love their mother." I do not know of a happier marriage. We, their children, reaped the benefits.
Fifty years ago, mid-1970s, in the heyday of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal, I participated in NYC in an all-day healing service with Ruth Carter Stapleton, sister of President Jimmy Carter and renowned Evangelical healer. Her prayer engaged emotional suffering in "healing of the memories." We called to mind negative memories and then invited, imaginatively, Jesus to enter and transform the memory. I found it to be powerful and am puzzled that it seems to have disappeared with her. She led us slowly through our entire lives, starting with conception. When I recalled (imaginatively, of course) my conception, my mind went to the immediate prelude, the spousal embrace of my mother and father. I received a deep, powerful surge of Joy, pure Joy. Not physical, not emotional, but surely intellectual and spiritual. I believe that was some mystical participation in the Joy of their marriage.
Lay Catechist
The ambitions that have shaped my life are simple and straightforward: faith, family, amateur philosophy, catechesis, and friendship with the poor. I self-identify as Non-Professional (or lay) and Anti-Careerist in my aversion to the monopoly of career as definitive of personal identity. Beyond my family life, my defining ambition, identity and mission has been to be a lay catechist.
"Lay" here has two meanings: non-ordained and non-academic-expert; neither clergy nor certified (doctorate) in the academy. While I revere Holy Orders and respect the academy, for myself I prefer the lay, the vernacular, the ordinary, the populist, the secular style. The non-clerical are positioned to make a very significant witness to Christ, in the world. The non-expert, uncredentialed thinker is free to wander across the academic disciplines, unrestrained by protocols, and draw from unconventional, organic, populist sources of wisdom. The non-ordained, non-experts enjoy a privileged position.
To "catechize" is to "echo" the voice of Christ, in the Church, in a specific time and place within history. And so, the catechist studies: Scripture, Church teaching and history, his culture and history. But this occurs in the context of a specific worshipping Church. While Pope Francis recently instituted a formal category of "catechist" within the Church, the charism and service has generally been charismatic, spontaneous, organic and flowing from the Holy Spirit. It is not clear that institutionalization will help.
From the beginnings, the Church has enjoyed distinct "orders"... some institutional and others more pneumatic and fluid: apostles, martyrs, virgins, widows, hermits, monks, anchorites, stigmatists, friars, priests, deacons, and so forth. Catechists may be the most underrated.
I recall, with immense gratitude, lay catechists who have inspired me.
Personal Friends
In my personal life:
John Rapinich, ex-beatnik, autodidact, charismatic, artist, poet, pro-lifer, convert, Neo-Cat, eccentric, mystic, amateur theologian and best friend.
Pat Williams, librarian, autodidact, marine, family man, catechist, homespun philosopher.
Sister (of Charity) Patricia Brenan and lay women of the charismatic Community of Hope who instructed us in the charismatic dimensions of Catholicism. Later in life we were mentored by Sister Joan Noreen, founder of Our Lady's Missionaries of the Eucharist.
Additionally I have worked closely with outstanding catechists: Sister (of Charity) Maria Martha Joyce, Sister (Felician) Marilyn Minter, Brother Ray Murphy, and Stephen Adubato.
Great Catechists of our Time
Let's list and consider the great lay catechists of the last 80 years.
Pride of place, for creativity, depth, passion and influence is shared by Kiko Arguello (with Carmen Hernandez) of the Neocatechumenate, Chiara Lubich of Focolare, and Ralph Martin, Steve Clark and others of the Charismatic Renewal.
Next: Frank Sheed and Maisey Ward, Rene Girard, Gil Baile, Peter Maurin and Dorothy Day, Heather King, Ross Douthat, Catherine de Hueck Doherty, Adrienne von Speyr, Caryl Houselander, Madeleine DelBrell, Sister Ignatia ("angel of AA"...please do google her.)
Philosophers
A related group: lay Catholic philosophers. In the Catholic world, philosophy and theology, although distinct, mutually infuse and overlap because reason and faith are wed together. Theology looks primarily to Revelation and its articulation in the Church. Philosophy receives this same revelation but engages more with secular philosophy (Aristotle, Plato, Kant, Hegel, etc.) as well as the entire universe of human culture. It is notable that the great Catholic philosophers of our time are all lay: Charles Taylor, Etienne Gilson, Jacques Maritain, Edith Stein (vowed but not ordained so "lay"), Josef Pieper, Alasdair MacIntyre, David L. and David C. Schindler, Peter Kreeft, Gabriel Marcel, Dietrich von Hildebrand, Elizabeth Anscombe, Louis Dupre, Remi Brague. The singular clerical philosopher of such caliber would be St. John Paul, personalist and phenomenologist.
Sidebar (for philosophy buffs only):
The two greatest philosophers of the 20th century, Martin Heidegger and Ludwig Wittgenstein, were both baptized into and buried in the Catholic Church. Their life and thought, in between womb and tomb, not so Catholic. Heidegger was a non-theist, a womanizer (famously with Hannah Arendt) and a Nazi. Wittgenstein was tormented in conscience by his practice of homosexuality. Both knew and rejected the intellectualism and realism of Catholic Thomism. Both articulated passionate spiritual concerns, but as non-cognitive and existential. Wittgenstein's close friend and prime disciple was the brilliant Catholic Elizabeth Anscombe who helped to get him buried in a Catholic manner. Heidegger studied under the great Husserl whose best student was Edith Stein (Saint Theresa Benedicta of the Cross). Stein and Anscombe were the greatest Catholic woman intellects of the century. How striking that they were both so close to these two dominating geniuses. The friendship of Anscombe/Wittgenstein was intimate and loving to the end. That of Stein/Heidegger was hostile: he refused her assistance with her dissertation and tried to devalue her contribution to a book honoring Husserl. He was a Nazi philosophical celebrity; she died in Auschwitz. Consider the contrast: two male geniuses, victims of their sexual compulsivity and trapped in the fog of doubt, uncertainty, unknowing, and confusion...the two Catholic women, radiantly feminine in their empathy, chastity, fidelity, receptivity, and integrity of body/emotions/intellect/soul, and yet virile in their intellectual certainty and clarity.
Authors
Another adjacent community: lay Catholics who reflect our faith in literature. My favorites: Flannery O'Connor, Graham Greene, Frank O'Connor, Myles Connolly, G.K. Chesterton, Tolkien, George Bernanos, Sigrid Undset.
Politicians
Looking to politics for witness to our faith is a huge disappointment, especially in the USA. Of its nature, politics involves combat, compromise and moral ambiguity. It is particularly inhospitable to clarity of witness to Christ. Most prominent Catholic politicians in the last 50 years are Democrat and pro-legal abortion. This extends tragically beyond the usual rogues gallery (Kennedys, Cuomos, Bidens, Pelosi, Kerry) to talents like Tip O'Neill and Patrick Moynihan. Right of center Catholic are often compromised on other values: notably, the immensely talented, recent-convert JD Vance in his embrace of the ugliness, crudeness, isolationism and exaggerated combativeness of MAGA. Other outstanding figures have darkened their legacy by their abuse of women: JFK, Caesar Chavez, and Jean Vanier. The list of public Catholic who retained an integral witness to our faith is lamentably short. On the left: Sargent Shriver, Robert Casey Sr, Eugene McCarthy, Mayor Flynn of Boston. On the right we find: Henry Hyde, Marco Rubio, Paul Ryan, John Boehner, Justice Barrett, Alito, Scalia, Thomas, Roberts. None of these are without flaws.
Beyond our borders the list is also short. Servant of God Julius Nyerere, of Tanzania, is a standout. The creators of the postwar Europe are also exceptional: Venerable Robert Schuman (France), Konrad Adenauer (Germany), Venerable Alcide de Gasperi (Italy). A favorite of mine, largely unknown in the USA, is the flawed but passionately Catholic Portuguese Antonio Salazar.
Movies
Hollywood, like politics, is a world thick with moral hazards and forces hostile to Catholicism. But amidst the darkness, light does shine: directors John Ford, Alfred Hitchcock, Frank Capra, and Mel Gibson as well as actors Mark Walburg, Jimmy Caviezel, Sylvester Stallone, Jonathan Roumie, and Gene Kelly.
Conclusion
Surveying, from the perspective of 80 years, this horizon of lay catechists, within the Church and beyond in culture, is inspiring. We do stand on the shoulders of giants. In a Church polarized and confused and a world darkened in so many ways, may each of us, in our own domains, similarly echo the voice of Christ and radiate his light.
Come Holy Spirit!