My Theological Dream Team

In a previous post , (May 13, 2026) after contrasting two 10-man teams of Jesuit thinkers, one progressive and the other orthodox Catholic, I announced the "Fleckinstein Fantasy Theologian Competition." But I did not give my own dream team. So I offer now, my first and second team.

Criteria:

Intellectual brilliance, creativity, insight; depth and breath of erudition; fidelity to Tradition; holiness of life; range of influence.

First Team

1. Pope St. John Paul

2. Pope Benedict

3. Balthasar

4. Kiko Arguello

5. Ralph Martin

6. Monsignor Luigi Giussani

7. Edith Stein/ St. Theresa Benedicta of the Cross

8. Avery Dulles

9. David L. Schindler 

10. David C. Schindler 

Second Team  In no order of ranking.

Rene Girard

Jacques Maritain

Etienne Gilson

Dietrich von Hildebrandt

Karl Stern

Romano Guardini

Fulton Sheen

Scott Hahn

Henri de Lubac

Raniero Cantalamesa

Notes:

- John Paul is the singular theological champion of our time. He, along with Benedict and Balthasar, forms a cohesive, synthetic theology that draws deeply from Tradition and Revelation, engages modernity, and authoritatively interprets the Council. Their work is definitive for our Church in our time.

- After those three is a second triumvirate of spiritual leaders of the renewal movements: Kiko, Martin and Giussani.

- Four Americans who I have personally known make my first team: R. Martin, Dulles and the two Schindlers. These have greatly impacted the American Church, perhaps not so much global Catholicism.

- Note the strong preference for a creative Thomism that incorporates the best of modernity, especially personalism and phenomenology: John Paul, Stein, Benedict, Hildebrandt, Blondel, Maritain, Gilson and in some degree all of the 20 thinkers.

- St. Theresa Benedicta of the Cross (Edith Stein), the only woman on the list, merits special honor for her brilliance, holiness, heroism in death as Jewish and Catholic martyr, and her drawing from classical Catholicism as well as the best of contemporary thought to plumb the mysteries of empathy, femininity, and the cross.

Conclusion

Our Church in our time has received extravagant theological wisdom, through these and others. With this heritage, we can suffer serenely the infection of progressive confusion, indecision, and compromise afflicting our hierarchy. It is now our delight and destiny to plumb the depths of these riches.

Mary our Mother, Seat of Wisdom, pray for us! Help us to receive, cherish, defend, enhance and share the heritage we have received.