Friday, November 20, 2026

In Praise of the Lay Catechist: Reflections after 80 Years

Today, I privately, quietly celebrate 80 years of existence. Born 8/20/1947, my conception calculates roughly to Nov. 20, 1946, 80 years ago today. A good time to look back, reflect, give thanks.

Exulting in a Holy Memory

My first, prime blessing: the love  between our mother and father.  Modest, discrete, and chaste in classic Catholic form, they were in love...tenderly, reverently, passionately...for over 50 years. They exemplified the wisdom: "The best thing a man can do for his children is love their mother." I do not know of a happier marriage. We, their children, reaped the benefits.

Fifty years ago, mid-1970s, in the heyday of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal, I participated in NYC in an all-day healing service with Ruth Carter Stapleton, sister of President Jimmy Carter and renowned Evangelical healer. Her prayer engaged emotional suffering in "healing of the memories." We called to mind negative memories and then invited, imaginatively, Jesus to enter and transform the memory. I found it to be powerful and am puzzled that it seems to have disappeared with her. She led us slowly through our entire lives, starting with conception. When I recalled (imaginatively, of course) my conception, my mind went to the immediate prelude, the spousal embrace of my mother and father. I received a deep, powerful surge of Joy, pure Joy. Not physical, not emotional, but surely intellectual and spiritual. I believe that was some mystical participation in the Joy of their marriage.

Lay Catechist

The ambitions that have shaped my life are simple and straightforward: faith, family, amateur philosophy, catechesis, and friendship with the poor. I self-identify as Non-Professional (or lay) and Anti-Careerist in my aversion to the monopoly of career as definitive of personal identity. Beyond my family life, my defining ambition, identity and mission has been to be a lay catechist.

"Lay" here has two meanings: non-ordained and non-academic-expert; neither clergy nor certified (doctorate) in the academy.  While I revere Holy Orders and respect the academy, for myself I prefer the lay, the vernacular, the ordinary, the populist, the secular style. The non-clerical are positioned to make a very significant witness to Christ, in the world. The non-expert, uncredentialed thinker is free to wander across the academic disciplines, unrestrained by protocols, and draw from unconventional, organic, populist sources of wisdom. The non-ordained, non-experts enjoy a privileged position.

To "catechize" is to "echo" the voice of Christ, in the Church, in a specific time and place within history. And so, the catechist studies: Scripture, Church teaching and history, his culture and history. But this occurs in the context of a specific worshipping Church. While Pope Francis recently instituted a formal category of "catechist" within the Church, the charism and service has generally been charismatic, spontaneous, organic and flowing from the Holy Spirit. It is not clear that institutionalization will help. 

From the beginnings, the Church has enjoyed distinct "orders"... some institutional and others more pneumatic and fluid: apostles, martyrs, virgins, widows, hermits, monks, anchorites, stigmatists, friars, priests, deacons, and so forth. Catechists may be the most underrated. 

I recall, with immense gratitude,  lay catechists who have inspired me.

Personal Friends

In my personal life: 

John Rapinich, ex-beatnik, autodidact, charismatic, artist, poet, pro-lifer, convert, Neo-Cat, eccentric, mystic, amateur theologian and best friend.

Pat  Williams, librarian, autodidact, marine, family man, catechist, homespun philosopher.

Sister (of Charity) Patricia Brenan and lay women of the charismatic Community of Hope who instructed us in the charismatic dimensions of Catholicism. Later in life we were mentored by Sister Joan Noreen, founder of Our Lady's Missionaries of the Eucharist.

Additionally I have worked closely with outstanding catechists: Sister (of Charity) Maria Martha Joyce, Sister (Felician) Marilyn Minter, Brother Ray Murphy, and Stephen Adubato.

Great Catechists of our Time

Let's list and consider the great lay catechists of the last 80 years.

Pride of place, for creativity, depth, passion and influence is shared by Kiko Arguello (with Carmen Hernandez) of the Neocatechumenate, Chiara Lubich of Focolare,  and Ralph Martin, Steve Clark and others of the Charismatic Renewal.

Next: Frank Sheed and Maisey Ward, Rene Girard, Gil Baile, Peter Maurin and Dorothy Day, Heather King, Ross Douthat, Catherine de Hueck Doherty, Adrienne von Speyr, Caryl Houselander, Madeleine DelBrell, Sister Ignatia ("angel of AA"...please do google her.)

Philosophers 

A related group: lay Catholic philosophers. In the Catholic world, philosophy and theology, although distinct, mutually infuse and overlap because reason and faith are wed together. Theology looks primarily to Revelation and its articulation in the Church. Philosophy receives this same revelation but engages more with secular philosophy (Aristotle, Plato, Kant, Hegel, etc.) as well as the entire universe of human culture. It is notable that the great Catholic philosophers of our time are all lay: Charles Taylor, Etienne Gilson, Jacques Maritain, Edith Stein (vowed but not ordained so "lay"), Josef Pieper, Alasdair MacIntyre, David L. and David C. Schindler, Peter Kreeft, Gabriel Marcel, Dietrich von Hildebrand,  Elizabeth Anscombe, Louis Dupre, Remi Brague. The singular clerical philosopher of such caliber would be St. John Paul, personalist and phenomenologist.  

Sidebar (for philosophy buffs only): 

The two greatest philosophers of the 20th century, Martin Heidegger and Ludwig Wittgenstein, were both baptized into and buried in the Catholic Church. Their life and thought, in between womb and tomb,  not so Catholic. Heidegger was a non-theist, a womanizer (famously with Hannah Arendt) and a Nazi. Wittgenstein was tormented in conscience by his practice of homosexuality. Both knew and rejected the intellectualism and realism of Catholic Thomism. Both articulated passionate spiritual concerns, but as non-cognitive and existential. Wittgenstein's close friend and prime disciple was the brilliant Catholic Elizabeth Anscombe who helped to get him buried in a Catholic manner. Heidegger  studied under the great Husserl     whose best student was Edith Stein (Saint Theresa Benedicta of the Cross). Stein and Anscombe were  the greatest Catholic woman intellects of the century. How striking that they were both so close to these two dominating geniuses. The friendship of Anscombe/Wittgenstein was intimate and loving to the end. That of Stein/Heidegger was hostile: he refused her assistance with her dissertation and tried to devalue her contribution to a book honoring Husserl. He was a Nazi philosophical celebrity; she died in Auschwitz.  Consider the contrast:  two male geniuses, victims of their sexual compulsivity and trapped in the fog of doubt, uncertainty, unknowing, and confusion...the two Catholic women, radiantly feminine in their empathy, chastity, fidelity, receptivity, and integrity of body/emotions/intellect/soul, and yet virile in their intellectual certainty and clarity.

Authors

Another adjacent community: lay Catholics who reflect our faith in literature. My favorites: Flannery O'Connor, Graham Greene, Frank O'Connor, Myles Connolly, G.K. Chesterton, Tolkien, George Bernanos, Sigrid Undset. 

Politicians 

Looking to politics for witness to our faith is a huge disappointment, especially in the USA. Of its nature, politics involves combat, compromise and moral ambiguity. It is particularly inhospitable to clarity of witness to Christ.  Most prominent Catholic politicians in the last 50 years are Democrat and pro-legal abortion. This extends tragically beyond the usual rogues gallery (Kennedys, Cuomos, Bidens, Pelosi, Kerry) to talents like Tip O'Neill and Patrick Moynihan. Right of center Catholic are often compromised on other values: notably, the immensely talented, recent-convert JD Vance in his embrace of the ugliness, crudeness, isolationism and exaggerated combativeness  of MAGA. Other outstanding figures have darkened their legacy by their abuse of women: JFK, Caesar Chavez, and Jean Vanier. The list of  public Catholic who retained an integral witness to our faith is lamentably short. On the left: Sargent Shriver, Robert Casey Sr, Eugene McCarthy, Mayor Flynn of Boston. On the right we find: Henry Hyde, Marco Rubio, Paul Ryan, John Boehner, Justice Barrett, Alito, Scalia, Thomas, Roberts. None of these are without flaws.

Beyond our borders the list is also short. Servant of God Julius Nyerere, of Tanzania, is a standout. The creators of the postwar Europe are also exceptional: Venerable Robert Schuman (France), Konrad Adenauer (Germany), Venerable Alcide de Gasperi (Italy). A favorite of mine, largely unknown in the USA, is the flawed but passionately Catholic Portuguese Antonio Salazar. 

Movies

Hollywood, like politics, is a world thick with moral hazards and forces hostile to Catholicism. But amidst the darkness, light does shine: directors John Ford, Alfred Hitchcock, Frank Capra, and Mel Gibson as well as actors Mark Walburg, Jimmy Caviezel, Sylvester Stallone, Jonathan Roumie, and Gene Kelly. 

Conclusion

Surveying, from the perspective of 80 years, this horizon of lay catechists, within the Church and beyond in culture, is inspiring. We do stand on the shoulders of giants. In a Church polarized and confused and a world darkened in so many ways, may each of us, in our own domains, similarly echo the voice of Christ and radiate his light.

Come Holy Spirit!




Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Catholic Conscience and Public Health Policy

 In a complex society like ours, public health policy is an urgent, unavoidable need; we require sound, clear thinking founded in moral principles. But this field poses challenges for the Catholic, even as the field needs that influence.

To start, policy in general but surely health policy is entirely dominated by liberal or progressive values and ignores conservative concerns. A 2018 survey of epidemiologists  (in American Journal of Public Health) found 72% of respondents liberal-leaning and 4% conservative-leaning. By contrast a 2024 survey of practicing physicians found 32% liberal, 43% moderate, 22% conservative. 

It is obvious that the policy field in general appeals to the progressive intellect, which highly values science, technology, education and an assertive central government. By contrast, the conservative view resists centralized power and social engineering by a professional elite as it values freedom from control and subsidiarity, trust in smaller institutions starting with the family and Church. And so, especially in health policy there is a pronounced antipathy in the field to inherited Catholic principles.

Covid

Our recent pandemic is a great case study. I am not one to greatly lament public policy of the time. There was immense uncertainty and anxiety, especially at the initial outbreak. I appreciated the overall policies and the reassuring posture of Dr. Fauci and Dr. Birx. Now, with the benefit of hindsight, we have a clear perspective. In general I view the guidance and policies as reasonable, given the uncertainty and panic. But certain mistakes do stand out.

First and foremost: the authoritative claim of Dr. Fauci in particular that he was "following the science." Public policy is not science; it does not simply "follow science;" although it does build upon evidence. First of all because often the science itself is uncertain. We now know that guidelines about things like masks and distance were not scientific at all, but rather exercises in common sense and prudence. My view is that the experts did their best and did a decent job on the whole. But the truth is that policy decisions always come out of moral, subjective presumptions, which are not scientific at all, as well as prudential evaluations of the anticipated consequences upon the public.

Most notoriously, Fauci and his crew fiercely resisted the lab theory in favor of the market explanation even as evidence pointed in the opposite direction. We now know that Fauci was heavily invested in "gain of function" research with the Chinese and world health organizations. So, he was denying the science to defend his prior commitments. He was passionately, systemically denying the science. This brilliant man was in denial of his own biases, even as he arrogantly robed them with the seemingly infallible authority of science.

Perhaps the most pernicious error was the extended closing of our schools. This had particularly toxic effects on the poor. This was largely the workings of the teachers' unions which prioritized  their own anxious self-interest over the needs of the most needy students. Catholic schools and red states who opened schools earlier look very good in hindsight. 

For this Catholic however, the most inexcusable and obnoxious policy was the absolute closing of the Churches. Our Churches are mostly large and allow for adequate distancing. However, we were deprived of the sacraments, including funerals and Sunday mass. There was no need for this. Our bishops for the most part complied, implicitly granting that the sacraments were not "necessary." Meanwhile, bars, gyms and all sorts of institutions were operating. When the Black Lives Matter rallies exploded, these were allowed with hundreds congregating together, as somehow "necessary." This is the most vivid manifestation of the anti-Catholic bias of the field.

The Cultural Divide

With the Sexual Revolution of the 1960s, our society divided morally-spiritually-culturally into two opposing cultures around two issues: the value of incompetent human life and the meaning of sexuality. The conservatives retained their God-fearing reverence for all human life, however small or disabled, and their esteem for sexuality as sacred, reserved for marriage/family in chastity, fidelity, fecundity, and stability. The cultural progressives reconfigured incompetent, indeliberate and disabled human life as without intrinsic value and so embraced abortion, reproductive technologies, euthanasia and assisted suicide. They liberated sex from spousal commitment and children and allowed it as recreational or primarily interpersonal and romantic.

The linchpin for this revolution was artificial contraception. By the 1970, over 90% of women, including Catholics, were technologically contracepting at some point. This changed the entire culture. As foretold by St. Pope Paul VI in Humanae Vitae in 1968, this technique opened the floodgates to abortion, pervasive divorce, widespread promiscuity, pornography, the approval of homosexual acts, and more. The Church was largely defenseless: natural family planning was only being developed at the time and the Theology of the Body of St. John Paul was mostly in his own intellect. Catholic sexual ethics was demeaned as repressive, ignorant, and condemnatory. Progressives would later advocate widespread artificial contraception as the key to making abortion rare; but the inherent logic and dynamic is the opposite. The prior choice to "contra-cept," to avoid a child technologically, when unsuccessful calls ineluctably for abortion as a backup. Contraception and backup abortion became the foundation of a new culture of free sex; a welcome development for toxic, ungenerous, non-paternal males.

We remain locked in this Culture War of over 60 years with the Democratic Party championing the liberationists and the Republican Party the traditionalists. There is near parity between the two sides as we see in the swings back and forth between elections, usually with close counts in voting. But the progressives dominate the upper tiers of society, the elites in academia, entertainment, law, media and medicine. 

And so, the field of public health policy is overwhelmingly built upon progressive moral/philosophical principles.

An Example

My Physician Assistant daughter, in training 25 years ago, was distressed in observing an authoritarian gynecologist.  The young mother had several children already; did not want to conceive again soon; but had reservations about contraception. She was not forceful or articulate about her reasons. The doctor was insistent that contraception was the only correct path ahead. The wholesome, effective when properly practiced Natural Family Planning method was not for this doctor an option. The many adverse physical effects of the pill were not discussed. My daughter used this incident to present her case study in ethics at Allentown College of St. Francis DeSales. This was a act of courage as even at that time the field of medicine was largely progressive. This same daughter told me just today that she applied for a position in an Urgent Care center but could not be hired as she would not be able to prescribe the morning-after pill. The center is between two colleges and there is heavy demand for that abortion pill.

Conclusion

Does this mean that a conscientious Catholic cannot or should not practice medicine or public health? Not necessarily! But it does mean the field is filled with moral hazards. The practitioner needs to be deeply versed in Catholic moral ethics in order to maintain integrity and bring the influence of our faith into an often ambiguous, confusing field.

The agenda of Cultural Progressivism has adopted as "health care" does not come from good science but from moral chaos and confusion: euthanasia, transgender chemicals and surgeries, abortion, reproductive technologies and other new and emerging disorders.  Biological health is build upon sound moral/spiritual principles: self-control, temperance, chastity, stability, fidelity, the sacredness of sexuality and of every human person, however incompetent. 

The Catholic health policy practitioner has much to bring this field. She will need to deepen her grasp of our tradition and pray for the gifts of prudence and wisdom from the Holy Spirit.





Saturday, November 14, 2026

Highly Recommended: The Pilgrim

 The Pilgrim is a marvelous EWTN 6-episode (less than an hour each) series that follows a elderly pilgrim who wanders rural England, visiting Churches, praying his Catholic devotions, and dramatically engaging sinners in crisis. He encounters: an adulterous middle aged man, a PTSD veteran who has just murdered in rage, a miserable spinster, a pair of wild young men fascinated by their friend's embrace of the monastic vocation, the rivalrous wife and mistress of a recently deceased man, and so forth.

The pilgrim is a repentant sinner, a mystic, deeply pious, direct and candid about sin, evil, faith and God's love. It is a contemporary British version of the classic Russian Orthodox Way of the Pilgrim which chronicles a similar but 19th century holy wanderer. That type, like the "holy fool," is a staple, of course, for Russian Orthodoxy but not so common in Catholicism. Both pilgrims are homeless, wandering from holy place to holy place, always in prayer, encountering all kinds of surprises, good and bad. 

It calls to mind the remarkable (Highly Recommended for family on Disney +) movie The Straight Story, a true, inspiring journey of Alvin Straight across the Midwest to reconnect with his estranged brother. He travels slowly in a John Deere tractor-lawnmower and has adventures in his Odyssey. This film is remarkable as it was directed by David Lynch, whose other movies are dark and perverse. 

The series recalled own formative experience in walking the Camino of Santiago across northern Spain about 20 years ago. My pilgrimage had none of the spiritual drama of this series. I was alone with only a few, less consequential encounters. But the quiet, solitude, Churches and the natural beauty were there for me.

Each episode is very slow, quiet, peaceful as much of it follows the protagonist across lovely country sides, over bridges, to magnificent ancient Churches and graveyards, with soft background of nature sounds, especially birds. This is NOT a fast-moving thriller. It is prayerful or it is pure boredom. 

The pilgrim is eccentric: his clothes are dignified, but old and shabby, always a tie and sweater; he loves his pipe and his strong coffee; he prays on his large rosaries and recites in Latin; he is friends with the monks. He has about him an abyss of tranquility. But he speaks very clearly about sin. At one point he admits that his mission is the conversion of England. This is ridiculous of course; but in God's grace it is sobriety, zeal and magnanimity. 

He reminded me of my best friend, John Rapinich, another eccentric, holy, gifted, beatnik, poet, artist, charismatic,  NeoCat, autodidact itinerant. Actually, I have been blessed over my lifetime to befriend and be befriended by many such outliers: unconventional, intuitive, sensitive, intelligent, devout, and utterly delightful. 

In fiction the closest character is Mr Blue, Myles Connolly's aberrant, urban mystic, utterly unconventional, non-bourgeois, free and exultant in spirit.

A  similar type is found in secular movies: the mature, seasoned, wise man who is unsuccessful and not accomplished, but  humbled and chastened by his own failures. Robert Duvall (Tender Mercies, Get Low, The Apostle) and Paul Newman (Nobody's Fool, Cool Hand Luke) are superb in such roles. Such men are, by conventional, bourgeois standards, failures and losers. But acceptance of their own weaknesses endow them with a serene, wise, generous spirit. 

When I was graduating college, 1969, and leaving seminary with zero career ambitions, my friend Tim Hull told me:  "I picture you walking down a dirt road in some third world country, kicking a can." I received that as a great compliment at the time. I have treasured it since. In The Pilgrim, I find a clarification, an intensification, a deepening of that ambition: he is everything I want to be as I soon embark on the ninth decade of my own odyssey home.

, 


Monday, November 9, 2026

The Troubled Soul of Donald Trump

Last night on 60 Minutes Ross Douthat did an extraordinary interview of Donald Trump,  the first extended interview since the midterms. Pressing  him clearly, firmly with hard questions on a range of topics, Ross maintained a courtesy, a respect, an emotional serenity. This seemed to calm the President who voiced the usual nonsense, but himself remained tranquil, reflective and even accepting of the historic events. No election denial. He seemed to be unaware of how critical Douthat has been of him over the years.

The conclusion was astonishing. He asked about the state of his soul, before God, as he considers his death. Wow! At age 80 Trump is surely aware of his mortality. He seemed to be, after this marathon of rallies, fatigued and therefore pensive. Ross, a solid Catholic, is aware that we are in November, the last month of the Church calendar, the month of sanctified and suffering souls, of the last things of death, judgement, heaven and hell. He moved seamlessly from the political, the historic, the immanent to the transcendent, the eternal: the destiny of his soul. 

Trump's response, immediate and spontaneous, was revealing: "I hope I am missed." In the face of death, he does not fear annihilation or condemnation, he does not long for God, nor does he does  presume heaven. He wants our attention, our approval, our affection. He wants to be loved. Emotionally, he is a needy, even infantile person.

He said that as a religious person he believes in God, heaven and hell. He expressed a hope for heaven but seemed very uncertain about it. At this point, the finale, Ross discards his identity as sage-investigator and goes full blast prophet, confessor, spiritual director. He asks: before Christ at your death, will you be able to forgive your enemies, Comey, Pelosi and others? His response is clear and firm: No. I will not forgive them. They are bad people and have done bad things. I will not forgive them. He is definite. He is hard. There is no softness or ambivalence. He is in the mortal sin of hatred.

In this he revealed his own soul, but also the heart of his MAGA movement. The core: hatred. This populist movement is a mixture of many policies, but the emotional power springs from resentment and anger. Trump is such a lightening rod for the diabolical energies of MAGA ... in a way no one else can mimic ... because he is himself possessed by the spirit of hatred. He himself admitted that he could shoot someone on a NYC street and his followers would remain loyal to him. This is because however bad he is, he still embodies their hatred of the liberal elite.

Clearly, he is  a sinner, a public sinner, in need of our prayers. He is not Catholic. He is baptized and therefore a Christian, part of the body of Christ. He is our President and therefore elicits our loyalty. Now that he is thrown off his pedestal of power, he is a pathetic, pitiable person. I do not myself find this difficult: I have a soft spot in myself for him. Melania is Catholic, apparently, in a pious and private manner. We pray for all of them: Jared, Ivanka, and the family.

I find it easy also to pray for Bill, Hilary, Barak and Michelle...all non-Catholics, deeply misguided but also decent in many dimensions. My challenge is prayer for disloyal Catholics, Joe Biden above all. 

In a different flavor, yesterday's news also included a clip of George W. Bush riding bike across his ranch with disabled veterans. With the passage of time, by comparison, the simple, modest decency of that president, and his father, becomes more pronounced. 

It is good for all of our souls that we pray for the eternal destiny, forgetting about politics for a time, of our leaders. Trump needs prayer. Don't we all?

Happy November: month of saints and souls, thanksgiving, death, judgment, heaven and hell.

Sunday, November 8, 2026

The Four Streams of Love

What is love?

Dictionary definitions see it as a feeling, emotion, attachment, attraction or affection. These are clearly reductionist as emotivist. Yes, love is a feeling; but is much more than that.

More philosophical, moral minds insist it is an act of the will, a concern for the other, a disposition of generosity and even self-sacrifice. This is an improvement, but remains reductive as moralistic. Yes, love is a decision, of will-guided-by-intellect; but is much more than that. 

Love cannot be defined in light of other realities since it is the absolute, primal, foundational, original principle of reality. It is coextensive with Being itself. How do you define being? existence? reality? They are immediately, intuitively obvious, as self-manifesting. The attempt to define in other terms is immediately futile.

Human loves...in all their complexity, nuance, depth, ambiguity, promise...remain vulnerable to futility, frustration and tragedy...unless they realize their true nature. They all flow from, reflect, and flow to, the Absolute, Eternal, Tri-Personal Drama/Event of love within the Holy Trinity. Human loves only become coherent, purposeful, integral, and sustainable when seen as reflections, icons, sacramentals...finite, tentative, provisional...of the great, abiding, infinite Love of the Trinity.

Let us again ponder the varieties of human love. C.S. Lewis, in his classic The Four Loves, revived the classic Greek typology:  Storge as affection, body-based; Philia as friendship of equals joined in a common engagement;  Eros as desire;  Agape as selfless, sacrificial concern for the other. Here we again prefer an alternate four-part typology around the loves of the family: filial, of the son/daughter for father/mother; paternal/maternal as delight and tenderness; fraternal/sororal of brother and sister and friend; and spousal, the mutual desire of bride and groom. This paradigm is less abstract and more concrete, grounded in the realities that structure every human family.

Filial love incorporates storge love of affection into a deeper spiritual reality. It is the primal love of the human person as creature: receptive. The embryo/infant/child is receptive of parental love, broadly understood. This is physical, emotional, and eventually intellectual, social, spiritual. It is the primal pleasure and joy of comfort received that nourishes trust as the foundational attitude towards life. This develops further into gratitude, appreciation, reverence and eventually adoration of the Creator. This is the fountain from which every human love will flow. This is the core love of every creature.

Paternal and Maternal loves are best not abstracted into "parental love" so that they retain their grounding in nature, biology, and the ontology of gender. But their inner form is identical in its twofold focus: delight in the little Beloved, and tenderness of care for the little one in her fragility, vulnerability and suffering. Delight here is distinct from pleasure or satisfaction; it is not merely a feeling; it is the intellectual-contemplative-emotional-spiritual engagement with the little one as true, good and beautiful. This is accompanied by the passion to nurture and protect her against any threat. This passion of protection, even in the animal kingdom, is the strongest natural instinct, even exceeding the desire and delight of lovers. (In my opinion.) Arguably this is the love that most resembles the divine. It is groBunded in the physicality of storge as it consumes itself sacrificially in the love of agape.

Fraternal/Sororal or Friendship love is identical with philia.  It is the mutuality of equals as engaged in a common enterprise: family, sport, politics, religion, art, etc. It is free of the neediness of filial love, of the heavy duty of parental concern, of the flaming passion of spousal desire. There is mutuality in delight, respect, care and desire...but all in a lighter manner. What binds is not that mutuality so much as a third, shared reality that engages, a faith, mission, interest, hobby or goal. So it is a tripod: two friends and their shared concern.

Spousal Desire is equivalent to eros  understood in the broadest, deepest sense. We of course know the "erotic" as physical desire or attraction. This is  included in eros or spousal longing but is far from being everything. A deeper aspect is romantic, emotional or psychological attraction. This is stronger as it draws from deeper psychic needs. Both of these, however, are basically need-based attractions and not really love in the truer sense of valuation of the other, beyond one's own needs or desires. Such desire can be selfish, passing infatuation and, frustrated, be easily transformed into hatred and resentment. Such attraction is itself wholesome and good, but only within the context of  and infused by deeper, stronger forms including charity (agape), reverence, tenderness, selfless delight, and shared openness to transcendent values.   

Christian, especially Protestant, thought (Nygren) has sharply contrasted agape  and eros as opposites which exclude and deny each other: the first generous, selfless, Godly; the second selfish, lustful, sinful. It is true that eros on its own is vulnerable to perversion into domination, violence, control. But even the lowest forms of need-based desire (of the infant, of the animal, of the injured person) are in themselves good. In addition, there are higher forms of eros  which are more deeply, intensively wholesome: the desire for genuine beauty, truth and goodness. Here we have the artist, the scholar, the journalist, the activist in passionate pursuit of justice. These too are forms of desire. More profoundly still: our inner desire for God's very self. We are created to desire God: this is Eros. This is good. 

Even deeper still: the love of God for us, properly understood, is not pure agape, oblation and sacrifice, bereft of desire. God does desire us. He created us out of generosity but also out of desire for us, a yearning to share with us his eternal joy, a yearning for us as delightful to him. This was not need based. It was generosity-based desire. 

And so, we see in every love the operation of desire along with generosity. The infant desires the attention of mother and father; and this is very good. Friends and siblings enjoy each other and their shared interests. The mother and father desire their little one, in an entirely wholesome, generous manner. Lastly, of course, spousal desire includes but transcends the physical and emotional into the generative, altruistic, personal, aesthetic, moral, and spiritual. 

Spousal love  uniquely flows from mutuality in desire but is even more profoundly grounded in fraternal/sororal or philia love, the more stable reverence for each other and united engagement with transcendent realities, including family and God. In lesser degree, spouses or lovers engage with each other ... creatively, fluidly, organically ... in filial/parental love. In the dance of matrimony one responds to the others need and vice versa. But that is, of course, not the focus of the relationship.

Love and Time

Living in the fragility and tentativeness of time, we are always pilgrims, journeyers moving and changing, drawn by grace to the Kingdom of Heaven. And so our human loves are tentative, finite, and vulnerable. We move from infant love to maturity, from one friendship to another, from romantic love to seasoned love. No earthly love can satisfy the profound erotic longing of our God-desiring hearts. 

At the same time, every genuine human live is a sharing in the infinite love of the Trinity and so it endures, as memory, in the enduring life of God and thus triumphs over death intrinsic to time. Every kind act, every friendship and romance, every heroic act...abides forever in the eternal heart and intellect of of God.

Pope Benedict

With incomparable clarity and depth, Pope Benedict, in his classic Deus Caritas Est, illuminated the interior harmony of eros and agape. In human (sinful) life they often contrast. But in God they infuse and illuminate each other. God gives to us in oblation, sacrifice and generosity; but out of a desire for us and for union with us. He imagines the ladder of Jacob, with angels ascending and descending, as showing the love of God, descending generously as it ascends from the abyss of human desire and need. The two are in perfect accord. 

The Love of Christ

We leave the best to last. In our Lord Jesus Christ we see every human love as reflective of the love of the Trinity. 

Filial: Christ, loyal son of Mary and Joseph,  is the Son of God: perfectly, absolutely receptive of and reflective of all the love and being of the Father. 

Paternal: Christ comes to us from the heart of the Father to die for us, to pardon, to save, to give eternal life.

Fraternal: Christ is our friend, brother, captain and king.

Spousal: Christ is Bridegroom of the Church his Spouse: he burns with desire to give himself and set fire to the earth.

Every specific human love is a unique combination of these four loves. Every one of our personal, human loves, however humble, is a share in this magnificent Drama of Love.


You have made us for yourself, Lord, and our hearts are restless until they rest in You.  St. Augustine


 


Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Asymmetry of Man and Woman

 Asymmetry is a lack of similarity, balance, or proportion between two parts. It suggests a tension, a dissonance. For example, your left and right hand are largely symmetrical as they face each other in different directions but one is dominant as in left-or-right-handed.

In the Catholic world we are highly aware of the complementarity of man and woman: that we balance and compensate each other to make a more complete unity in marriage and family and beyond. This is true enough. Our seven children would agree that they benefited from the contrasting masculinity/femininity of my wife and I. But that spousal communion never reaches a climax of harmony, serenity and balance. There remains always frustration, misunderstanding, annoyance, conflict. Part of the mystery of gender is this very tension/dissonance that is not resolved in this life. We will soon celebrate 56 happy years of marriage. The tension does not diminish with age; in fact it heightens in some dimensions with decline in physical/psychological stamina, energy and resilience. It is essential that we clearly accept the inevitable asymmetry between male and female. It is not a negative, but a fruitful tension if handled in wisdom, charity, patience and faith.

A minor example: the humor of the male, as in teasing,  is often aggressive, crude and even sexual. To the woman this is at best childish, at worst offensive and repugnant.  This dissonance does not resolve itself but tends to persist despite good intentions for mutual sensitivity.

Men and women do not think alike. For example, in moral thought and behavior, women are compassionate, intimate, intuitive, generous. Men are more detached, objective, rule-and-principle oriented. No, these realities are not to be dismissed as stereotypes. They are part of reality.

The two mature at different paces. Teaching CCD to 7th graders, I marvel at the disparity at age 12: the boys are little boys, physically and emotionally;  the girls mostly tower over the boys in height but even more in emotional maturity. The boys will catch up, but it will take a very long time.

Women in large part do not understand men. Innocent but naive young women with curvaceous figures cluelessly dress in fashionable tight-fitting clothing. If they could read the minds of men who see them they would be horrified.

Men in large part do not understand women, especially in their sensitivity and vulnerability. We do not know the harm we have done with our infidelities. I exhort my brothers: Let us pray passionately for purity of heart, that we clearly see our women in all their preciousness, that we repair the harm we have done!

From this fundamental asymmetry definite truths emerge.

- The biggest possible error is the romantic illusion that a lover will satisfy, complete and fulfill you. The idea of a "soul mate" who matches you in perfect symmetry. This is a recipe for disaster. Big reason about half marriages fall apart. In popular culture this is the dominant myth. It prevails also in the delusion of "gay marriage."

- Men and women each need strong, close, sober friendships with their own sex. These have to satisfy much of the emotional need we all carry. We of the same sex naturally understand each other; can support each other properly.

- The Catholic practice of same-sex education, especially in high school, makes a lot of sense. Educators can address the specific needs of men and women. The distractions of attraction, flirtation and jealousy are helpfully diminished. Focus is on learning, friendship, sports and other activities.

- It is extremely rare for a man and woman to sustain a very close (BFF) relationship over a period of time. In the famous When Harry Met Sally argument, Sally won the argument as they did not maintain a longtime non-sexual, non-romantic relationship. They fell for each other, sexually and romantically. But another reason such a relationship is unlikely is the asymmetry: men and women rub each other the wrong way, much of the time. Without contrary attractions of sex/romance and the mission of family, social pressures and expectations, not to mention shared faith in Christ, it is very rare for such a relationship to prevail over time.

- Homosexuality, lacking the fruitful tension of asymmetry, is a fraudulent, deceptive mimicry of conjugality: not complementary, not unitive, not fruitful, not asymmetric; it is a monotonous, violent, pathological symmetry, like Narcissus gazing at himself in the pond. As a cultural movement...pride, parades, podcasts, flags...it is flamingly histrionic and self-righteous. Inherently, it is sterile and self-destructive.

- Finally, a realistic approach to marriage is to anticipate great joy and satisfaction, but along with that misunderstanding, hurt, disappointment, and conflict. In the catechesis of Kiko Arguello, couples are guided to expect mutual crucifixion: we crucify the ones we love, the ones closest to us. On our own resources we cannot overcome such sin and suffering. If we each draw close to Christ, in conversion and trust, we receive from the Holy Spirit the ability to ask for forgiveness, and to give forgiveness. In this we overcome the asymmetry and draw each other deeply into the love of the Holy Trinity which alone satisfies and completes us.

Saturday, October 31, 2026

Our Church Polarized, Confused, Betrayed; and the Loyal Catholic Resistance

Now almost 18 months into his papacy, we see that Leo...prayerful, slow, cautious, deliberate,  steady, serene, irenic...is true to his word: he is continuing the program of Francis.  This is a sadness, a disappointment for many of us. We are betrayed in crucial areas of our received Catholic faith. But first, a thumbnail review of five recent papacies (the most recent both dual-pontificates.)

Postwar Stability and Expansion. Pope Pius XII, 1945-58. Especially in the USA, the Church was steady, thriving, confident, expansive; united against the global adversary, atheistic Communism; moving across the globe, especially the global South, in missionary fervor, cultural influence, and aid to the suffering. Time-tested, stable institutions stood serenely as alongside them, in full view, movements of renewal quietly flourished: ecumenism, Scripture, social justice, role of the laity, centrality of religious freedom, acceptance of pluralism, dialogue with Judaism and world religions, and positive engagement with modernity.

Vatican Council Renewal. St. Pope John XXIII and St. Paul VI, 1958-68. Tremendous church change within even greater cultural revolutions.

Confusion and Chaos. St. Paul VI, 1968-78. Widespread catechetical/theological confusion; progressivism takes charge of Catholic academia; loss of vocations; decline in church participation; widespread collapse of institutions. At the same time, lay renewal movements gain in strength. 

Restoration. St. John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI, 1978-2013. Grounding of the Council reforms in continuity with tradition. Catholic Catechism. An extraordinary body of papal teaching from both pontiffs. Lay renewal movements continue to surge in influence.

Return of Confusion and Polarization. Pope Francis and Pope Leo XIV, 2013-Today.  Impulsive, incoherent campaign to reconcile with theological progressivism and Chinese communism. In this they have betrayed fundamentals of Catholicism.

1. Chinese Church has been abandoned into the hands of the Communist Party. The underground Church, loyal for 80 years to the Pope, has been betrayed. The Party now unilaterally designates bishops and controls them. John Paul and Benedict, knowledgeable about communism, refused to sign such an agreement. This is a disloyalty of enormous proportions. I can recall no comparable abandonment of so many Catholics into the hands of such a  hostile enemy. Cardinal Zen stands as a solitary witness against this.

2. Spousal-Sexual Ethos ... centrality of chastity and conjugal fidelity...  of John Paul and Benedict, traditional and yet fresh, is renounced in favor of a truce with cultural progressivism, including feminist and LGBTQ militancy.

3. Latin Mass, center of Catholic life for 1500 years and source of inspiration for young families, is dictatorially crushed.

4. Deconstruction of the Episcopacy.  Synodality continues to replace bishops' authority with a group-process parliament of endless grievance, introversion, and progressive manipulation. Meanwhile, in important Vatican offices,  lay people assume positions of authority and governance traditionally reserved to those in holy orders.

5. Clerical Intrusion into the lay domain of politics. As the laity are clericalized into Church governance, the Vatican assumes a global  role as "caliph" responsible for world peace, justice and order. And so, the hierarchy intervenes on contentious, chaotic, prudential and properly lay policy affairs including immigration, borders, war, economy, climate and other. The distinct missions of clergy and laity are convoluted.

6. Just Use of Lethal Force of State to defend the common good and the innocent...in war, police work and capital punishment...as always understood by the Church is replaced by a vague, vacuous pacifism s in denial of the hard realities of evil.

Loyal Catholic Resistance

It is imperative that those of us who know and love our Catholic legacy resist the Francis/Leo hegemony and that we witness to Truth received... always in loyalty, humility, clarity, decisiveness and love.

The clearest resistance to date has come, at least in the USA, from the laity: First Things, EWTN, etc. In the hierarchy we have Zen, Burke, Scola, Mueller, Sarah, and more. The best example of such truthful resistance is the clear, absolute refusal of the entire African episcopacy to cooperate with blessing of homosexual unions. Another encouraging incident: Bishop Barron recently corrected Cardinal Vesco who said we do not want to convert Jewish and Muslim believers. We need more of such virile candor, courage, confrontation and correction from our prelates. We are in fact in a war within the Church, even a holy war on behalf of Revealed Truth handed down to us. We can no longer "make nice" with deference to the Pope and avoidance of conflict. "I have come to bring the sword" is the way Jesus put it.

In Outliers, (2008) Malcolm Gladwell considered the horrible safety record of Korean Airlines in the 1980-90s. Their accident picture was 17 times worse than that of American Airlines despite comparable training, competence and mechanics. The problem was the culture of extreme deference to hierarchy and authority: subordinate pilots would not confront or correct their superiors out of a dysfunctional respect. Their accident picture corrected itself with the introduction of a more direct, confrontational, less hierarchical safety culture.  Something like this has to happen with our Church. We need from our bishops virile, vigorous candor and confrontation.

Big Picture

The institutional hierarchy is essential to and constitutive of the Church. But it is not everything. The Church is best understood as the Mystical Body of Christ, the Communion in holiness of saints (militant on earth, suffering in purgatory, triumphant in heaven), as our Mother, as the Bride of Christ.

Christ, in the Holy Spirit, is intimate with his Church in so many ways besides the hierarchy: primarily the prayer and charity of saints, including the humble, anonymous ones; ordinary priestly ministry and parish life; and an infinity of works of mercy, religious life, gatherings in prayer, holy families, and so forth.

I return always to my "Fr. Burke Principle." Fr. John Burke (you recall dear Reader), pastor of my parish from before my birth until when I left at age 18, was rarely seen and when seen was odd. Was it alcohol? Emotional distress? Unknown. But what was clear is that the work of the Church went on smoothly: priests, brothers, sisters, families, school, sacraments, births and deaths. Distress and dysfunction of priest/bishop/pope does not stop the workings of the Holy Spirit.

In my single positive experience with physical therapy I learned that the weak, wounded bone would recover slowly as the adjacent muscles were strengthened by exercise. And so, with the Church: dysfunction in the Vatican and in much of the episcopacy need not discourage us. Our Lord is present to us in so many ways. We open our hearts, minds, and action to the Holy Spirit in our distinctive places and missions. Our Lord will correct the hierarchy in his good time.

Let us pray that Truth, in Love, prevail across the entire Church, especially in the Vatican and the episcopacy!

 

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Catholic Eccentrics and Centrics

An eccentric is someone "off center," different, odd, idiosyncratic, non-conventional, weird, not a normie. Sometimes it is used positively in the sense of entertaining, endearing, comical, and refreshing. By "centric" I here mean one who is properly centered, grounded, and balanced. We will see that the two do not exclude each other.

We were blessed in our family of nine (with another two fosters) by a mother and father who were strongly centric: grounded in their Catholic faith, tested and tried in youth by the Depression and WWII,  ever in love with each other. Everything else fell into its proper place. We were additionally graced with eccentric family members. My maternal Uncle Billy was a purple heart WWII vet, studied at Columbia University,  and spent his adult life as a mendicant entrepreneur in South America. All the time he was also an agent for US army intelligence, a spy. He lived a double life and never told a single family member. He was highly intelligent, hilariously funny, immensely idiosyncratic, a story teller, and a fascination for us. My paternal Uncle Jack was different: he fought with Patton and may have been  post-trauma. He was a loner, avoiding family functions; his wife,  agoraphobic, stayed home. He was in his 50s and still caddying when I started at about the age of 14. He had a job and so was not what we called "a rummy"... a drinker that caddied to pay rent and buy booze. He was affectionately called "duck" because of how he walked so I was nicknamed "little duck." I was not insulted; he seemed to elicit a quiet, respectful affection. Our great-aunt Agnes was a spinster who lived next door and was close to us. She was also "a character." She loved Robert E. Lee. This made sense as her father (my paternal great-grandfather) had fought for the confederacy upon arrival from Ireland, taught for a while as a Christian Brother, and started a dairy farm in West Orange, NJ.

I have delighted in a range of friendships over the years but am particularly drawn to eccentrics. For example, I have written about "maverick priests" whom I particularly cherish as interesting, insightful, afflicted, intuitive, entertaining, loving and lovable. I find them and they find me.

Here we will identify significant eccentrics and centrics of the last 80 years in the Church. 

Top Catholic Eccentrics 

These are important influencers within Catholicism whose thought was "off center" or different but in a way that was enriching, if not entirely balanced. Recall, please, that all our great reformers were eccentric in their time: Jesus and the apostles, Anthony, Benedict, Francis, Dominic, Ignatius and so on. These are prophetic figures who lean heavily and fruitfully into some reality of our faith, perhaps pushing the boundaries of our Catholic reservation in some way, but remaining overall loyal and offering us great enrichment. 

Kiko Arguello and Carmen Hernandez. Kiko left  bourgeois life and buried himself with the gypsies, taking his bible, guitar and ten dogs for heat. With Carmen, he developed an entirely creative, radical, orthodox, alternative Catholicism.

Ralph Martin and Leaders of Charismatic Renewal. Under the influence of the Holy Spirit, (in my view), in the wake of the Council starting in 1967, these integrated from Pentecostalism and Evangelicalism religious resources to create a distinctive Charismatic Catholicism which contrasted strongly with the dominant progressivism of the time.

Ivan Illich. Primarily a cultural critic rather than a theologian, he troubled the Vatican with his views but was voluntarily laicized to pursue his controversial advocacy. His was a most profound, broad critique of modernity (and the Church institution) as bureaucracy and technocracy. Similar views were advanced by non-Catholics Ellul, Berry, Goodman, Holt as well as Catholics Schumacher, Chesterton, Belloc.

Dorothy Day and Peter Maurin. Maurin was an itinerant, self-taught wise man who instructed Day in a distinctive, radical, love-the-poor Catholicism. They were hardcore Catholic but politically anarchist and pacificist and so eccentric within our Church. A charming, convincing disciple today is Larry Chapp, a "communio" theologian who left academia to start a Catholic Worker farm. He is a favorite of mine for several reasons. He is by far the most comical, entertaining, living Catholic theologian. He influenced my daughter and her husband in college. He is triply eccentric as anarchist, pacifist and universalist. But his love for Christ and the Church somehow overcome these flaws.

Rene Girard. With his groundbreaking, revolutionary anthropology of mimetic desire he has in effect created a new "center" for Catholic thought that is basically consonant with and enriching of our legacy. His thought has been wonderfully presented by his disciple Gil Baile. He is  more significant a contemporary thinker than Freud, Marx, Darwin or Nietzsche. 

Adrienne von Speyr and Hans Urs Von Balthasar. Balthasar is the most profound, encyclopedic, creative Catholic theologian of the 20th century. He deferred to his collaborator, the controversial mystic Adrienne von Speyr as more significant, especially for her annual Holy Saturday "descent into hell" which informed his theology of hell.

 E. Michael Jones. A cranky conservative Catholic, Jones is a brilliant cultural analyst and historian. His work is flawed by a pronounced anti-Judaism which returns to earlier Catholic bias and is much too close to antisemitism. He is especially prescient in criticism of Catholic conservatisms including Neoconservativism, Pentecostalism, and Marian apparitions at Medjugorje. He is second only to Jaki in combativeness.  

 Simone Weil. A brilliant mystic, she died out of solidarity with the poor and suffering in WWII, having refused baptism despite her love for the suffering Christ. She is strongly "out of center" but left us tremendous insight.

Paolo Freire, Oscar Romero, Gustavo Gutierrez, Don Camara.  These are the shining stars of a "liberation theology" which remains (precariously) within Catholic boundaries. They pushed our faith strongly into solidarity with the poor. Camara was archbishop in Brazil for 21 years and Mendez of Cuernavaca for 30 years. They had affinities with Illich. Cardinal Mueller, protege of Ratzinger, whose Catholic discernment is impeccable, strongly endorses liberation theology in the form offered by Gutierrez. Romero is a canonized saint.  

Top Catholic Centrics

These are Church leaders and influencers who have been centered, profound, orthodox, balanced in their teaching and witness, including their demeanor/style/action. Important leadership positions in the Church especially require strong centric personalities and thinkers. Representatives: 

Popes John Paul II, Benedict XVI, Paul VI, John XXIII, Pius XII.

Theologians Dulles, D.L. Schindler, DeLubac, Danielou, Congar, Boyer, Gilson, Maritain, Hildebrandt, Stein, Pieper, 

Cardinals Cantalamesa, Burke, Sarah, Mueller, Scola, Cooke, Suenens, O'Connor, George.

Bishops Varden, Barron. 

Special Cases

Popes Francis and Leo.

Bergoglio was a real eccentric: intense, volatile, impulsive, intuitive, emotional, intellectually incoherent. He was his own man. Creative and insightful, he was an excellent homilist and spiritual director, but a trainwreck of a pope. Above all a pope must be centric: holding everyone together, holding the Gospel truth in all its dimensions together. 

Prevost is deeply centrist in temperament, demeanor, and governing style. He looks for stability and especially unity in the Church. Theologically he is influenced by the progressivism of Francis and lacks depth, clarity and decisiveness in orthodoxy. 

Holy Ones Who Go "Catholic Weird"

Padre Pio, Mother Theresa, all stigmatists, healers, bi-locators, levitators, exorcists, hermits, and postmortem in-corrupts.

Eccentric Centrics 

The following were deeply centric in thought and life as they were eccentric, idiosyncratic and immensely entertaining in personality.

Blessed Fulton Sheen: flamboyant, histrionic; famously fought with powerful Cardinal Spellman over money for the missions;  and got in trouble late in life for his zeal for racial justice.

Mother Angelica: Immensely influential with EWTN as down-to-earth, populist, crusty Italian Catholic.

Monsignor Lorenzo Albacete: Sophisticated, NY, priest, writer-speaker celebrity; leader of American Communion and Liberation; hilariously entertaining; spent the last years of his life caring sacrificially for his disabled brother.

Flannery O'Connor: Immensely creative and entertaining; fiercely Catholic.

Fr. Stanley Jaki: Brilliant scientist/philosopher famous for his fierce combativeness.  

Elizabeth Anscombe: Protege of Wittgenstein; cigar-smoking, custom-defying, Humanae Vitae endorsing, atom-bomb condemning, mother of seven. Probably the most eccentric of all! 

Caryl Houselander: Inspirational writer who suffered anxiety and had an extraordinary, non-professional gift for helping those suffering mental and emotional anguish.

Heather King: Recovering alcoholic, convert, a contemporary Caryl Houselander.

Founders of the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal were largely eccentric centrics: Groeschel, Sudano, Fortuna, Pio, and Apostoli. 

The John Paul Institute for the Family in Washington DC seems to attract eccentric centrics: Adrian Walker, Paolo Prosperi, Michael Walker  and others are balanced by sound centrics like Healy, Schindler, Antonio Lopez and others.

Stephen Adubato, curator of "Cracks in Modernity," a friend, and the most promising up-and-coming eccentric centric.

Conclusion

Notice that most of these were alive and active during and after the Council. Those were the years of my own adolescence and early adulthood. There were times of immense ferment in the Church. These significant figures are orthodox theologically, but moving zealously into prayer, contemplation and the mystical side of Catholicism. Many of them identify strongly with the poor and marginalized. They also include critiques of modernity as technological/bureaucratic/meritocratic. They coinhere in a traditional yet contemporary Catholicism that is renunciatory of cultural progressivism without being a retreat to a Church of the past.

Do you, dear Reader, share my delight, admiration, and gratitude in considering these inspiring, entertaining, radiant persons?  It has been a wonderful time to be Catholic!

Praise God!



Saturday, October 24, 2026

Exult!

 Recently, when I ask our Lord what he wants from or for me, I receive a single word: Exult!

Question: When I receive this word, is this a natural, psychological process, a kind of auto-suggestion? Or is it heavenly and supernatural, a movement of the Holy Spirit?

It is both; it is not an either/or. It is natural, ordinary, psychological. This word comes to me much as any random, meaningless word might: stone, boy, loud. It is not miraculous and unnatural like bilocation, stigmata or incorruption after death. But the fruit of it is that I feel very happy in relation to God; I experience a surge in confidence, zeal, fervor, fierceness, strength, courage, and longing for God. "By their fruits you will know them." So, with joy I receive and cherish this Word. The natural is oriented to, receptive of, and collaborative with the supernatural or spiritual.

Try this, dear Reader. Prayer is friendship with God: PAL...Praise and thanks; Ask...for yourself and others; Listen...for God's voice. So I invite and encourage and exhort you:  Ask Jesus what he wants for you or from you. Then sit quietly, peacefully, patiently, hopefully. And wait.  And wait.  And wait. You may or may not hear a word. If you do, that word may well be random and meaningless. But it may also be a comforting, healing, strengthening Word from God.

"Exult" is an interesting word: it means to rejoice, to experience and manifest extreme joy, often after a victory.

The Latin root "exsultare" means literally to leap out. It means to "jump for joy." It is interior but manifests physically, powerfully and spontaneously. 

We see this in sports. Your basketball team wins the championship with a jump shot at the buzzer in a third overtime. Fans and players all spontaneously jump for joy. Victory! Triumph over the opponent! Sheer joy!

It is associated with military victory. Imagine El Cid and the Reconquista; the victory at Lepanto; the images of VE Day on May 8, 1945. 

It is close to the word "exalt" which is to praise and glorify someone. The etymology: Latin "exaltare" which means to "lift up." This clearly occurs mostly in liturgy in which we glorify God, especially recalling his marvelous deeds. We remember the Israelites as they see the waters destroying the hostile Egyptian chariots. We share in the Resurrection Joy of the apostles and disciples in that 40 days of glorious presence. 

As I write this, dear Reader, I am not quite sure if the word I heard was "exult" or "exalt." What I understood was the intense joy of exult joined with glorification of God. And so, I think (again): it is not either/or but both/and.  It is intense, manifest, fierce Joy, in God's goodness and works.

In this life on earth we are never entirely in the victory, in the way when the buzzer rings and our team is up by one or when Germany and Japan surrendered officially. We are always in the battle. But, by anticipation/expectation/hope, we already exult/exalt. We are like the underdog team that is down but fiercely determined to win. By anticipatory exaltation/exultation, we are zealous, energized, hopeful, fervent, confident, fearless, reckless, already-exultant-exaltant. 

I invite, encourage and exhort you, dear Reader, let us together exult-exalt in the Lord, his works, his intentions!

Friday, October 23, 2026

Foundational Virtues of Virility

 "The defining catastrophe of our time is the crisis in masculinity."    Fleckinstein

Our "virtue" and "virility" both derive from the Latin "vir" which refers in the Roman world to a freeborn masculine person, as distinct from "puer" (boy) and "homo" (human person). It connotes honor, dignity, strength and goodness. Virility...or manliness or masculinity...indicates the masculine as good: as strong, generative, paternal, protective, energetic, forceful. 

The core aim of the Cultural Revolution of the 1960s was, among other things, to deconstruct virility as a form and as a representation of God the Father. It has been fabulously successful. We are suffering a catastrophic crisis in masculinity. 

The final aim of masculinity is paternity: the fatherly giving of life as representative of God our heavenly father. This includes but goes well beyond the merely biological. It begins as filial reception and response: of son to father and mother both. This develops into fraternity, friendship and brotherhood with both men and women. Then spousal or "groomal" (a rare but real word) intimacy with and loyalty to the bride. Finally, fatherhood: physical, emotional, social, intellectual and spiritual. And so we see the itinerary of virility: filial, fraternal, spousal and finally paternal.

The virtues which configure goodness in a woman and in a man are similar, but they take a different gestalt as there is distinction in identity, destiny and mission. For example, vices like vanity or timidity are less damaging to the character of a woman; but lack of empathy or generosity would be less ruinous for that of a man. 

Masculinity is, more than femininity, a discipleship, an itinerary, a process, an achievement. It requires deliberate rites of passage, tests, discipline, encouragement, competition and finally ordination. So it is important to be clear on the most significant virtues to be encouraged. The following seven virtues mutually infuse each other to form the interiority of virility.

1. Loyalty.

Loyalty is arguably the primal masculine virtue; infidelity the worst vice. Abandonment or betrayal of wife, friends, family, country or faith is the abolition of virility. This theme runs through all of culture, literature, and history. What is required, above all, is the proper hierarchy of loyalties. For example, mob movies are obsessed with loyalties: to the gang, the boss, to the brotherhood. However, since there is no underlying faithfulness to virtue, truth, charity, and God, the plot inevitably leads to dramas of betrayal. Likewise, dramas about men in other forms of conflict...police, military, etc...often center on loyalty to the brother that conflicts with fidelity to truth, justice or charity. Loyalty at its best of course is the martyr who dies for his faith or the hero who gives his life for his people.

2. Humility.

The final aim of virility is to image the Fatherhood of God. It is representational. Therefore, the foundational virtue is humility by which the ego of the person is deflated that his Self may reflect the glory, the honor, the love and the mercy of the Father. Problem: in the real, post-original-sin world, the strongest feature of masculinity is pride, the inflated and fragile male ego. And so, the ego must be reduced in order that the genuine Self, in Christ, resplendent in holiness and strength, be manifest.

3. Fortitude.

Virility as paternity images God as strong, protective, life-giving. Fortitude is both passive and aggressive. It is passive as patience, endurance, long-suffering and peaceful in adversity and suffering. It is active as courage, assertiveness, zeal, fierceness, valor, confidence and authority.

4. Chastity.

Purity of heart, including specifically sexual chastity, is required of virility lest it abuse  its power in toxicities of lust and covetousness or emasculate itself in fantasy flight from the real.

5. Sobriety and Serenity.

In addition to freedom from irrational enslavement to inebriation, lust, anger, anxiety, greed and ambition, sobriety here is interior peace that allows for contemplation, wisdom and prudence. Such deep, strong tranquility is a font of stability, energy and fruitfulness.

6. Justice. 

 The male mission ensures the objectivity, the harmony, the integrity of order. It is to do the right thing. It is distinct from Mercy: it does what is due; it does the right thing. Ultimately, in God, Mercy and Justice must infuse and inform each other.

7. Prudence.

Practical wisdom: the fruitful pursuit of the good through all the complex, dense, random and convoluted circumstances of life.

Conclusion

The great failing of Western civilization since 1965 is that we have failed to guide our young men on a path to these virtues. These might make the core curriculum of an itinerary into mature masculinity.

Note that we do not here address the essential theological virtues: faith, hope and love.

Other virtues are arguably as important as the above. Specifically, the core of the relationship of man to woman is tenderness and reverence. These entail compassion, kindness, generosity as well as esteem. These will flourish spontaneously, fluidly, organically in the mutuality of man-and-woman when there is interior to the man the foundation of the seven virtues here denoted.

The Good News: even in the catastrophic insanity of Cultural Liberalism, virility and femininity are irrepressible. There are ever resurging. They are inherent to the created order. 

Let us exult in our masculinity and femininity!






















: compassion, gratitude, kindness, generosity and more. These will flourish fluidly and spontaneously when the above are firmly in place.

Good news: even in the insanity of cultural liberalism, we see the resurgence of virility, along with femininity. They are inherent in the created order. They are irrepressible. They reflect the splendor, the truth, the holiness of God. Let us exult in them!









Wednesday, October 21, 2026

Top Ten USA Catholic Prelates of the Last 80 Years

 Considering holiness of life, breath of influence, competence, theological depth and clarity, my list:

1. Blessed Archbishop Fulton Sheen. Unrivaled for holiness of life, evangelical reach, intellectual brilliance.

2. Servant of Cardinal Terrence Cook. Competent, humble, holy man.

3. Bishop Robert Barron. Influential evangelist/catechist, first rate theologian, moderately conservative, appealing. 

4. Servant of God Bishop John Ford M.M. First Maryknoll seminarian and missionary to China, he was imprisoned by Chinese Communists, tortured and died a martyr in 1952. He is representative of the Tridentine, pre-Vatican II Church. 

And:  Servant of God Bishop James Edward Walsh M.M. Another pioneer Maryknoll missionary to China, he refused to leave his people and was in solitary confinement for 12 years, returning home in 1971 and dying at the age of 90 in 1981. A man of fierce zeal and immense talent, he served as unofficial representative of FDR to Japan in the years prior to WWII. 

5. Cardinal John O'Connor.  Charming, influential Catholic classic; ally of John Paul; fierce defender of Catholic interests in the culture war and also on behalf of the poor.

6. Cardinal Sean O'Malley.  Humble, holy, talented, Franciscan "man of the poor," he took over the Boston Church in the wake of the scandal and became a key advisor to Pope Francis.

7. Cardinal Francis George. A fine theological intellect, ally of John Paul/Benedict, and defender of religious freedom and Catholic interests in the Culture War.

8. Archbishop Charles Chaput. Much like Cardinal George, profound thinker and fierce culture warrior.

9. Cardinal Raymond Burke.  Formerly an important Vatican figure, he has stood steadfastly as a correction to the Francis/Leo pontificates.

10. Cardinal Dolan. Widely respected, lively, vivacious, intelligent, influential figure.

(You are right, dear Reader, that was actually 11!)

Most Saintly Prelates:

1. Blessed Fulton Sheen

2. Servant of God, martyr, Bishop Ford

3. Servant of God Bishop James Anthony Walsh M.M.

4. Servant of God Cardinal Terrence Cook

Greatest Theologians

1. Blessed Fulton Sheen

2. Bishop Robert Barron

3. Archbishop Charles Chaput

4. Cardinal Francis George

Most Troubled Legacies

Immensely influential and talented, the following made major positive contributions to the American Church, but also had serious negative impact.

Ex-Cardinal McCarrick  Now laicized and deceased, he is the face of the priest sex scandal. Super-energetic, talented, and charming he was a masterful fund raiser, a player in the Vatican, and a collaborator with John Paul when Archbishop of Newark. He became the leading episcopal progressive when he got his red hat and went to Washington DC. Notoriously, he misled the American episcopacy on the letter from Cardinal Ratzinger on the issue of communion for activist prochoice Catholic politicians.

Archbishop Weakland  Another influential progressive, his memory is tainted by the $450,000 settlement involving a homosexual relationship.

Cardinal Law, Cardinal Wuerl, Cardinal Mahoney These were prominent among the many prelates who neglected to address priestly abuse of minors. Otherwise, Law was a widely respected conservative, Wuerl and Mahoney leading progressives.

Cardinal Bernadine Arguably the most powerful American Cardinal since Spellman, he was a moderate, conciliatory, prayerful, immensely intelligent, competent and appealing figure. He is much like our current Pope Leo who came from Chicago. Amazingly he got an episcopal consensus on nuclear weapons. His most significant legacy is the "seamless garment" approach to life. He argued for a consistent approach that reverences human life in all dimensions including abortion, poverty, war, homelessness and so forth. He himself did not equate essential evils (abortion) with prudential judgments (tax policy, etc.) and distanced himself from liberal politicians who used this approach to allow support for abortion. However, since he did not strongly accentuate the difference, this has become a defining rationale for Catholic who support prochoice politicians. 

Other Considerations

Mid-Century Giants

A significant group of powerful cardinals presided over the immense expansion of the American Church in the 1950s into the early 1960. These were political powerhouses, in the Church and society, and competent builders. Often authoritarian. Not always known for theological acumen or piety. They epitomized the confident, aggressive, immigrant postwar Church. 

Cardinal Francis Spellman.  Archbishop of NY for almost 30 years, (1939-67) he was clearly the most powerful prelate of the era. Very close to Pope Pius XII, he exercised power in the Vatican, in American politics and dictatorially in his own realm. Fiercely anti-communist, he endorsed McCarthy and was the strongest Catholic supporter of the Vietnam War. On the negative side, he used seminarians to break a cemetery workers strike. He feuded with Sheen over money for the missions and retaliated by banishing him to Rochester. His legacy is mixed.

Cardinal Richard Cushing. Another long-serving prelate ((1944-70) in Boston, he was again a strong figure, a builder, a presence at the Council, an advocate for the poor/disadvantaged and for ecumenism and yet solid theologically. He was apparently a heavy drinker (which does not make him a bad person, necessarily). He was a close friend to the Kennedys. But this was before that tribe turned against their Catholic values so we cannot attribute blame here. He was (like Kroll) the classic postwar, liberal but rooted Catholic prelate.

Cardinal John Krol.  A little later (1961-88) this Polish Philadelphia Cardinal served at the Council and was a trusted advisor to John Paul. He was a competent builder, a faithful conservative, and president of the bishops conference in the turbulent 1970s. He is said to have been influential in garnering American support in conclave that elected John Paul.

American Prelates at Vatican II

As noted, American postwar cardinals were strong leaders and builders, not intellectuals. Cardinal Ritter of St. Louis and Meyer of Chicago were known as strong progressive voices. Spellman was more conservative but apparently went along with the liberal trend and famously brought John Courtney-Murray S.J. as a peritus on the significant document on religious freedom. 

American Vatican Insiders?

Other than Burke in his conflict with Francis, we do not address here Americans who have wielded influence within the Vatican. The most prominent, obvi: Pope Leo (Robert Prevost). In general, Cardinals in the Vatican do not get a lot of attention from the American press, except from Vatican watchers. (We recall John Allen of happy memory.) Vatican politics is mostly somewhat  quiet. 

Currently, Cardinal Kevin Farrell is strongly positioned in several offices and a progressive in the mode of Pope Francis. Leo clearly favors the Francis clique (Cupich, Tobin, McIntyre) although they are not influential within the American episcopacy. In recent memory O'Malley and Dolan were trusted by Francis. Other important figures: Rigali, Szoka, Levada, and Wright. It seems that generally Vatican service brings with it a degree of social modesty.

Conclusion

Considering our prelates of the last 80 years, we see a rich blend of holiness, human weakness, strong leadership, political maneuvering, and some theological excellence.   In  broad strokes, we can characterize these years:

1945-65 was a time of building with strong, urban, ethnic (largely Irish) figures like Spellman, Kroll, Cushing, Meyer, Cody and others.

1963-5 With exceptions, the American episcopacy was receptive of the Council. All good "organization men," they implemented it competently. Through the Paul VI years, the focus was on renewal and the changes. Powerful progressive forces, within and without the Church, including the media and the academy, drove things beyond the direction of the Council and our bishops. 

1978-Present. By the election of John Paul, the Cultural Revolution was in full bloom and had polarized the Church within itself. And so we might distinguish three models of episcopal leadership. Mediators tried to bridge the emerging gulf: Bernadine, McCarrick, and today Pope Leo and Farrell. Conservative culture warriors defend Catholic values with John Paul and Benedict: Kroll, O'Connor, George, Chaput, and Burke. Lastly, progressives have been encouraged by Francis in a rupture with tradition: Cupich, Tobin, McElroy, Weakland, and others.

We conclude, as in all things, with prayer for our bishops and cardinals.





Saturday, October 17, 2026

A Particular Catholic American Politics 2026

 Catholicism does not offer specific political ideologies or policies. It is a big mistake to consecrate some such system as "Catholic." In its social teaching we receive a loose network of principles to be used prudentially, flexibly, fluidly, creatively in different ways by different individuals and groups. They apply to every conceivable situation as they move us to bring all human life under God's grace and free us from evil and sin. These include: absolute dignity of every person however incompetent, the common good, solidarity (especially with the suffering and deprived), the brotherhood of all peoples, subsidiarity (emphasis on the small, concrete, immediate), conditional (not absolute) right to private property, rule of law, democracy, just war, sacredness of marriage/family/gender/sex, prudential balance between regulative state and free markets, and other. 

What follows are my political priorities in USA 2026 at the age of 79. They are not identical with my priorities 30 or 60 years ago. If I live another 20 years they will probably shift in emphasis with history.

1. Subsidiarity, "Benedict Principle" and Decline of Macro-Institutions

The Catholic politics I imbibed with my mother's milk in postwar America knew nothing of subsidiarity as it was enamored of big unions, which countervailed big corporations, which generated immense wealth for everyone, as they were regulated by big government, which triumphed over Nazism and eventually  Soviet Communism in maintaining a prosperous/peaceful global Pax Americana and battling racism, poverty, drugs, and later terrorism.

By contrast, subsidiarity prefers that the smaller social organizations, more immediate and concrete, handle situations when possible. This fundamental Catholic principle has become more important through my adult life with the malignant growth of huge organizations, particularly the nation state and global corporations. These have effectively swallowed up many smaller and intermediate institutions and rendered the isolated individual powerless against social gigantism. Our political left is enabling of an expansive, cancerous state; our left of malignant global capitalism.

Even more toxic is the moral degradation of our bipolar national politics. How could anyone with a head on their shoulders not be today a double-hater? It is my view that our 2020 presidencies, Biden and Trump 2, are by far the worst in our 250 year old history...in strongly contrasting ways. Both are startlingly incompetent, disconnected from reality in quasi-psychosis: Biden in debility and senility; Trump in a blindness of narcissism, resentment, grandiose mania and impulsivity. My personal animus is against Biden in his betrayal of "our family." An Irish, Catholic, working class, family man, he is my "Fredo." (Michael Corleone: "Fredo, you're my brother and I love you. But don't takes sides with anyone against the family, ever again.") Trump is nothing personal to me: he is not one of my own, not of my tribe. He is shamelessly, flamboyantly depraved in character; yet in the public realm he, mostly in his first term, has defended what is precious to our Catholic faith in his defiance of elite power.

And so we happily receive in this our time, from Rod Dreher and Providence, the Benedict Option. As the Roman Empire collapsed, St. Benedict did not defend or renew it, but retreated into monastic life. In time his monasteries spread across Europe and were the foundation of an entirely new, medieval civilization. And so, with the decline of our macro-society, we focus more closely on our immediate communities as we detach (emotionally, spiritually, intellectually) from the toxicities of public life. First, always, is our personal union with God: as we come close and open our hearts/souls to him, we become agents of his grace and mercy. Second, immediate family and closer bonds of mutuality. Eventually, strong families and communities of faith/value become fonts of grace, to enlighten all aspects of society.

2. Culture War

For half a century, from Roe 1973 to Dobbs 2022, our society was thrust into the Culture War around abortion and related issues. This caused many of us Catholics to switch our allegiance from the Democrat to the Republican party. This remains, in my estimation, the defining polarization of our time. This was clearly manifest in the campaign of Kamala Harris who spoke of nothing else but "woman's right of choice." As a single issue this dominates; but it flows into an entire way of life: euthanasia, assisted suicide, technological reproduction, cohabitation rather than marriage, embryonic stem cell research, denial of religious liberties, gay marriage, transgenderism and other. 

Significantly, Dobbs moved the issue mostly to the states and so relatively reduced its importance on the national level. Importantly it also returned it to the democratic process. The culture war remains but is not so important for our national politics. Since Dobbs, abortions have actually increased, largely due to the availability of chemical means. It also shows that the issue is rooted deeply in the new culture that exploded in the 1960: abortion, contraception, sterile sex, homosexuality, divorce, pornography, euthanasia, reproductive technology and the systemic abuse of women.\

For the foreseeable future, this remains the defining conflict of our time. We have not won this war; we may not; but it is morally incumbent upon us to fight it.

3. Internationalist

Globally, since childhood I have been a passionate internationalist. At the age of seven I learned of starving babies in China and I paced furiously back and forth in my house I was so troubled. This Catholic intuition of the brotherhood of all peoples has more than anything informed my politics. Through high school I was fascinated by the underdeveloped world, reading Maryknoll Magazine, America and NY Times. For four college years I studied to be a Maryknoll missionary priest. Today I consider myself a Catholic Neo-Conservative: supportive of a strong military, aggressive American posture across the glove, and fervently anti-MAGA out of a moral conservatism. This flows deeply from my Catholic values:

1. Solidarity with all people, especially those deprived and suffering. I was horrified by the Trump/Musk devastation of USAID. We can grant that these programs entailed waste, fraud and WOKE ideology. But the DOGE effort efforts directly deprived the needy even as it weakened our own "soft diplomacy" and global influence.

2. Realities of sin and evil. My worldview was formed by American contests in WWII and the Cold War. The defining binary of decision remains Chamberlain/Churchill. My Catholic faith alerts me to the drastic reality of evil actors. Today this is Communist China, Putin's Russia, Islamic terrorism (Iranian Shite and non-state Sunni), and related totalitarian imperialisms. Our country, in alliances like NATO, is uniquely capable of restraining these forces of evil. In the light of these radical evils, my Neoconservatism rejects selfish, chauvinist, xenophobic MAGA as well as progressive, quasi-pacifist, cosmopolitan delusions that such aggression can be prevented by diplomacy, education, science and therapy. Here I differ with Popes Francis and Leo.

3. Catholic, apostolic, missionary urgency requires that our Church have access to share our faith with every people. Therefore, we are morally required to resist anywhere the repression of religious freedom: Communism and Sharia Law, including that of Saudi Arabia and the gulf states. Generic fascism, often but not always, is not such a hindrance to evangelization. By this perspective, the Biden abandonment of Afghanistan is morally repugnant for many reasons but especially in that it leaves the entire country void of the Gospel, the Eucharist, the Church. 

4.  The dignity of the human person is best protected classic Western liberalism  by the freedoms (religion, speech, assembly, etc.), rule of law, democracy, private property, and markets. As we align ourselves with those who agree with this we serve the good of all peoples and our own interests in a peaceful, prosperous world. This is not cultural liberalism nor post-liberalism, but classic, Christ-based liberalism.

Clearly, my convictions here distance me from the cosmopolitan left as well as the isolationist right. But I am not completely alone. Currently, I am not opposed to our war with Iran as they have been at war with us and will continue to be. But I am nauseated with Trump's diesel fuel deal with Putin and his abandonment of the Ukraine.

Regarding globalized capitalism, I am morally ambivalent. It is true that millions have been lifted out of material poverty with adequate nutrition, water and other. This is not nothing. At the same time, however, corporate capitalism erodes traditional bonds of family, faith, location and community. It richly, inordinately rewards the investor class. It fosters envy, anxiety and resentment. It isolates and elevated the Sovereign Self. 

 But to the degree that it is accompanied by wholesome, family, religious values it can be good.

4. Economically: Moderately Left

In adulthood I have grown in my appreciation for capitalist initiative, market efficiencies and economic freedoms but retain my family's allegiance to governmental care for the poor, a strong safety net, unions, a robust regulatory system and a reasonably progressive tax program. I retain a strong class consciousness as loyalty to the poor and working class, free of resentment of the rich. I strongly renounce identity politics, anti-racism, DEI, and cultural Marxism. In this I align with the emergent Catholic-friendly, populist, culturally conservative, economically liberal New Right. (Sohrab Ahmari, Patrick Dineen, Adrian Vermeule, J.D. Vance.)

5.  "Christian Strategy" of Adrian Vermeule

Looking back to Old Testament patriarchs who served fruitfully in evil empires (Joseph in Egypt, Daniel in Babylon), Vermeule (First Things Nov. 1, 2017) proposes a "Christian strategy" by which we deny allegiance to any party, movement or ideology as we collaborate with any and all parties in specific actions for the common good. This is a marvelous strategy for our time. First, it balances the Benedict Option which risks complete detachment from the broader common good. Second, in our age of competing political depravities (of the left and right), it frees us from enmeshment in their toxicities. Thirdly, it brings us to acknowledge the valid good in any politics, even those we generally reject, and move our society in the direction of peace and cooperation.

Conclusion

Catholic social teaching is not a doctrinal system. It does not endorse any polity or ideology. It is fluid, organic, flexible, creative. It allows for the freedom, agency and ingenuity of the person and community in any circumstances. It encourages a genuine diversity of viewpoints.

Gloriously, the Church gathers us in the Eucharist, around the Word and Body/Blood of Christ, in the communion of truth and love, across differences of policy, ideology and viewpoint. Rooted in eternal truths, in stability, in permanence, it nevertheless respects, in prudential matters, viewpoint difference and conflict as fruitful and life-giving.  

As Catholics we can compete aggressively in the political arena, always serene, abiding in our revealed-received Truth and mutuality in Love.



Friday, October 16, 2026

Battle: the "Bachelor Individualism" of the Jesuits vs. the "Conjugal Mysticism" of John Paul II

The theological contours of our civil war in the Church since 1965 are clearly seen in the contest between the Jesuits and the John Paul papacy. Specifically, let us contrast the "bachelor individualism" of the former with the "conjugal mysticism" of the later.

Notoriously, Pope John Paul took charge of the Jesuits in 1981 to discipline and restore them. To the Catholic mind, this was startling. For 400 years the Society of Jesus, informed by the their fourth vow of loyalty to the pope, had epitomized Tridentine Catholicism as orthodox clarity, manly fortitude, evangelical zeal,  and academic excellence. The catastrophic collapse of Catholicism immediately after the Council finds exaggerated expression in the Jesuits. Their contest with John Paul on the mystery of nuptial or spousal love provides insight into the underlying issues of the Catholic Civil War that erupted in 1965 and still rages 60 years later.

In 1965, the Jesuit order had just under 8,400 priests, seminarians, brothers.  Today they number about 3,000 but shrinking steadily with an average age of 63. Quantitatively, they are 35% of what they were  50 years ago. But the qualitative change is more pronounced. 

It is not that all or even most Jesuits changed so drastically. Rather, institutionally the order changed, spectacularly in its universities and publications. The drastic turn to progressive values, contradictory of  traditional Catholicism, was led by a small, but influential group, a "critical mass." An opposing, but ineffectual minority resisted these changes. The vast majority of Jesuits (in my experience) are moderates, strongly aligned with neither side, pragmatic and pastoral, largely abstaining from the battle. But in its affluent, influential institutions, the order has been a primary advocate of an alternate, "enlightened," progressivism. The elite, the influencers... spontaneously, passionately, confidently, immediately...embraced the Cultural Revolution as it exploded after the Council. 

Why?

 Jesuits, Individualism and the "Bachelor Priest"

The Cultural Revolution at its heart enthroned the INDIVIDUAL as sovereign. It elevated the individual, the autonomous-competent-deliberative-agential Self as superior to all bonds and loyalties of family, Church, sacrament, nation, tradition, and God.

The Jesuit charism, centered largely on the autonomous Jesuit missionary, made it uniquely vulnerable to this individualistic progressivism. In sharpest contrast to monks, friars, cloistered communities and most active orders, the Ignatian charism is strongly individualistic: the 30-day Spiritual Exercises are personal, not communal; the nightly Examen; the private praying of the Liturgy of the Hours; and the overall spiritual culture. 

Fr. Charles Murr fondly recalls that while studying at the Jesuit Gregorian in Rome in the 1970s, he walked down the hall where the Jesuit professors lived at the time for vespers. The transoms over each bedroom door were open so that as he passed each room he could hear the priest praying aloud the psalms. (Practice at the time was to read aloud, not silently.) Every single door...a priest praying aloud...alone. This struck him in that it contrasted with the monastic and mendicant practices of communal prayer that preceded it.

The celibate Catholic priesthood has always been vulnerable to a "bachelor syndrome." The "bachelor" is a man not committed to wife and family, detached, alone, individualistic. Religious order priests compensate by their engagement in a community of prayer, brotherhood, and intimacy. The ordinary secular or diocesan priesthood lacks this dimension and so is especially vulnerable to a bachelor individualism. 

This is not an invincible impediment to a life of holiness and charity, but it is a difficulty to be overcome, for sure. Many priests succeed: they have wholesome family/friend relationships with women, devotion to our Blessed Mother, a filial intimacy with Holy Mother Church, a spousal relationship with the (bridal) Church they serve, strong priestly friendships, a virile/paternal identity and a deep prayer life.

Interestingly, the Ignatian charism deliberately cultivates individuality, here understood as intimacy with Christ, fortitude of character, patience in solitude and adversity. The Jesuit ideal is St. Francis Xavier, who travelled to the East to save souls. So, for 400 years, Jesuits were rigorously trained as heroic soldiers of Christ, prepared for hardship, persecution and martyrdom. They were trained to be free of community...Lone Rangers, without Tonto.  

Other groups resemble the Jesuits in this individualistic charism. I have familiarity with the Maryknoll Society of priests having studied to be one in my college years. The priests who taught us were men of sound moral character, deep personal faith, high intelligence, impressive agency and confidence. You did not sense among them a shared, communal spirituality. They were not attentive or close to us seminarians. Later, circa 1975, surging with the communal enthusiasm of the Catholic charismatic renewal, I read Come Holy Spirit by Servant of God Bishop John Ford M.M. He died in a Chinese concentration camp in 1952, having been the first Maryknoll seminarian and initial missioner to China in 1918. I was struck at the time by the pronounced individuality of the spirituality. For Martyr-to-be-Ford the Holy Spirit was not a communal, but a personal reality. It is the particular presence of God that was to strengthen him for decades of mission service, imprisonment and a martyr's death. This is bachelorhood at its best, as solitary heroism and sanctity. It is the Lone Ranger as Catholic saint.

Strangely, this Ignatian charism, iron-hard, tested and tried over 400 years in zealous mission labors, martyrdoms, combat with Protestantism, Fascisms, Communism, and paganisms of all sorts...collapsed into the Cultural Revolution 1965. Not only did it lack an immunity or resistance to the emergent cultural individualism, but it showed a propensity towards it. Two other aspects of the Jesuit heritage inclined it this way.

First, their high intellectualism. They spend years of study, detached from the practical and pastoral. Such abstraction carries dangers.  They are not rooted in a specific Catholic tradition in the manner of the Thomistic Dominicans. This was not a problem in the Tridentine Church which maintained its own academic traditions detached from the broader, secular society. But the Vatican II impetus to engage the broader culture pushed the Jesuits into the influence of Ivy League academia which was at that very time turning secular.

Another core principle of Ignatian spirituality is "to find God in all things." This assumes, of course, a closeness to God, a strong theology, and a capacity to discern the wheat from the chaff. In retrospect, me must judge that the individualism and intellectualism of the Jesuits did not prepare them to resist the siren call, in this new world, of Cultural Individualism. 

Individuality of Influential Mid-Century Progressive Jesuits

At the time of the Council (1962-65) we find a group of extraordinary Jesuits at the height of their influence: Courtney-Murray, Chardin, Lonergan, Rahner and then Arrupe who took charge of the order in 1965. Each embodied the Jesuit ideal: long lives of service to the Church, in a solitary fashion, in prayer and scholarship at once profound and encyclopedic. We might say they are "the last of the Mohicans"...outstanding in loyalty to the Church, intellectual brilliance, erudition, creativity, and personal piety. The problem: their theoretical work built upon the assumption of a bachelor-type individual, alone and isolated. This weakness made their approach vulnerable, especially in their disciples, to the toxicities of Cultural Individualism.

This is most evident in the  immensely influential Transcendental Thomism of Rahner and Lonergan. Famously, they labored to wed the metaphysical objectivity of Thomas with the Kantian "turn to the subject." This "turn to the subject" was the problem. It took as its starting point precisely the isolated Self, lonely and detached. They did not start from the Church in worship or the mystic in spousal communion with God. Lonergan attended to the dynamics of the human intellect. Rahner studied the interior longings and urgencies of the individual human spirit.  In this they resembled the Existentialism of postwar Europe in its fascination with the lonely, anguished individual suffering interior crisis. They did NOT take communion or, conjugality or family as their first building block.

Their slightly younger contemporary Avery Cardinal Dulles S.J. presents a distinct and illuminative image. Notice: Cardinal... He was honored by John Paul for his fidelity to Catholic tradition. In the 1980s-90s he stood as a solitary Jesuit in defense of basic Catholic beliefs in the face of  the progressive militance that swept over the Catholic academia. Particularly in the wake of John Paul's Ordinatio Sacerdotalis, Dulles fiercely defended the male priesthood. Part of his argument was that the priest represents Christ in his spousal love of his bridal Church so that his masculinity is intrinsic to the sacrament of Holy Orders. Here he reflected the "conjugal mysticism" at the center of the John Paul magisterium.

In this he distinguished himself from mainstream Jesuit theology of the time in its fashionable feminism. This shows he openness of his intellect. He was himself not strongly inclined to such "communio" or conjugal theology, but was personally a typical "bachelor Jesuit" in style and temperament, although a holy one at that. When I took his Fundamental Theology course in 1969 at Woodstock NY he was very positive about Rahner. Dulles did not fit into any school of theology but had an expansive mind that absorbed Truth from all corners, even as he was the sharpest of critics. In his classic Models of the Church (1974) he noticeably did NOT include "bride" and "mother" as significant models. He was himself not a participant in the Communio school of conjugal mystical theology. But he did clearly affirm their primary insights. He was himself surely the "Catholic Lone Ranger" and "Last of the (Jesuit) Mohicans."

And so, it is clear that the foundational realities...women priests, contraception, homosexuality, legalized abortion, leftist politics...in which the Jesuit leadership systemically renounced Catholic tradition for progressivism...all build upon a fundamental "bachelor individualism" and indifference to or rejection of the spousal basis of Catholicism as articulated authoritatively by John Paul, Benedict and their school.

Conjugal Mysticism

The clear, distinctive theological school of John Paul, Benedict, Balthasar and their comrades has been well described as "conjugal mysticism" since it finds in marriage a foundational image for our communion with God and it places immense importance on the actual reality of marriage and family. This is a continuation of the "Resourcement" theology that developed strongly after WWII and largely informed the Council itself: DeLubac, Danielou, Congar, Bouyer, and others. They "returned" to the patristic sources, even as they remained rooted in basic Thomistic metaphysics and engaged contemporary thought.  Influenced by classic Thomists (Gilson, Maritain, Pieper), they strongly engaged contemporary phenomenology and personalism (Stein, Hildebrandt, Blondel, Marcel, Buber). Their focus on the person differed from that of Rahner/Lonergan in that primacy was placed upon relationship, communion and marriage/family. Pronouncedly in John Paul's Theology of the Body and the fierce Catholic view of gender in Stein and Hildebrandt, we find a spousal mysticism that places the masculine/feminine reality at the center of Creation and Providence. And so, in a marriage of traditional with contemporary thought, new life springs from Catholic practice of the sacraments of matrimony and holy orders, the fecundity of sexuality, the holiness of the family and new life.

With a few notable exceptions (Oakes, Pacwa, Fessio), the Jesuit theological guild ignored when it did not oppose the conjugal mysticism and the theology of the body of the dual pontificate. In this they reflected the broader Catholic academy. John Paul brought his announcement to the Catholic laity largely without the the mediation of our dominant intelligencia. Or more accurately, he attracted a small, alternate cadre (West, Everet, Janet Smith, Waldenstein, and the entire international John Paul Institute) to lead a revolutionary,  populist, theological movement.  

In large measure, influential Jesuits resisted. Already in 1964 the Kennedy family convened at Hyannis Port a gathering of progressive theologians, many disciples of Courtney-Murray, including Jesuits Fuchs/Drinan/McCormick,  to lay the groundwork for Catholic support of legalized abortion. Richard McCormick along with leading Jesuits and their schools forcefully rejected Humanae Vitae (1968), although John Ford SJ strongly endorsed it and Arrupe clearly exhorted his order to obedience. Presidents of the prestigious Jesuit colleges joined in the infamous Land of Lakes Conference (1967) which declared Catholic Academy's independence from the hierarchy. And, finally, we have the Catholic LGBTQ movement and its encouragement by our Jesuit pope.

We see clearly a Church divided in its anthropology, its view of the person. Within the Jesuit order we find a "bachelor-individualist" version of Cultural liberalism which champions individual rights: women can be priests and abort, gay sex deserves full honors, and the conjugal imagery is diminished to honor the autonomous, independent, agential Self. On the other side, we have the Conjugal Mysticism which exalts the masculine/feminine as reflective of the unity/diversity of God as Trinity.

Conclusion

Our entire, received Catholic legacy is founded upon the sacredness of marriage as reflecting our spousal communion with Christ: the holiness of marriage and orders, the virginal-bridal form of the religious life, our rigorous sexual ethic, the mystery of femininity/masculinity, the foundational form of the natural family, and the reality of the person-in-communion. 

Catholic, largely Jesuit, Progressivism proposes an alternate anthropology: the autonomous, sovereign Self...sterile, contracepting, same-sexing, "choosing" of abortion and gender, solitary rather than maternal/paternal. 

In response to the Cultural Liberalism which exploded in 1965, John Paul and his cohort have given us a traditional-yet-contemporary Catholic proposal that is encouraging and inspiring in its moral and intellectual splendor. This is a wonderful time to be Catholic.